top of page
Search

Mbiras in 4th, 5th and 6th Grade. How I Ditched the Recorder and What I Switched to.

Apr 16, 2021
4 min read

Updated: Apr 26, 2021

I wanted to love the recorder. Let me start by saying that. I wanted to be able to use it to not only help my students become musically literate, but also take that knowledge and put it to the test! Which the recorder did help to do!

(I am really big into being musically literate- for more information click the link below)

My students did improve on their ability to sight read, count rhythms, identify letters/solfege for treble clef and perform independently and as a group.

However the recorder also came with

  • Weak plastic that the kids assumed was a toy

  • Inability to use it during COVID-19 times for health reasons

  • Squeaks, screech, and shudders

  • The knowledge of who messed up

  • The frustration and embarrassment from the student that messed up

  • Inaccessible to students of varying needs

  • Spit...so much spit

  • Bad embouchure practice for future instruments

My class would get so caught up with these problems that we would only get to half of what I had planned! Luckily for me I discovered the mbira as well as the recorder and bucket drums which you can read about in my other posts. With different names around the world the mbira is thought to have originated in Zimbabwe by the Shona people. The mbira is found in many different countries under different names and different forms.


Full Discloser

I am not hating on the recorder as a valid instrument! I believe the recorder can sound incredible when played by someone who can do it right! I simply believe there are instruments better suited to a child’s first instrumental experience


Full Discloser #2

I am by no means an expert when it comes to the mbira and I am learning more and more about the instrument, the culture who plays it, and the history behind it every year I teach. I am just as open with my students that if I don’t know the answer to a question they have, or if they know something I don’t know, that I am 100% willing to search and try my best to learn and discover the answer with them.



The mbira has helped to give my students the confidence to improvise, compose, play as a group and as an individual all while enhancing their sight reading, rhythm counting, and overall musical skills.


Positives and Negatives

Positives

  1. The second you take a mbira out it has that “wow” factor. Students are automatically interested in something that looks and sounds as beautiful as this instrument does.

  2. The mbira is loud enough that when played as a group you can hear something that sounds absolutely stunning.

  3. The instrument is quiet enough where if a student makes a mistake it tends to blend in as well.

  4. Opens a door for exploration of other cultures

  5. Simple design and layout

  6. Simple to make sound good-immediate confidence boost

  7. Storing is easy. I bought mbiras that came with a sturdy case that will be great if we ever need to travel. I will put the link below.

  8. Extremely sturdy while looking delicate. This helped to make proper care of the instrument important.

  9. Opens a door for composition

  10. Extremely sanitary any time of the year. For COVID-19 times I did label the cases to avoid contamination.


Some Negatives

  1. The mbira that I purchased is c maj only. There are no sharps or flats readily available however, there are many varieties. You can also change the pitch by moving the tines.

  2. Teaching this instrument virtually, along with all instruments is difficult. I found many apps and virtual tools that I will link below to help combat this.

  3. It can be tough on a budget.

    1. I petitioned my school at the beginning of fall 2020 for instruments I could use with my students and got enough money to buy 40 mbiras for about $1,000 in total. Each was about $25.



My approach is different with each grade so I can make the experience valuable and challenging as they progress with the instrument, however, we all start roughly the same


  • Connect from piano to the mbira- the mbira uses the exact same notation as piano, but the layout of the instrument is different depending on what mbira you purchase. I start by connecting the piano(which they are familiar with from 3rd grade) to the mbira

  • Listen to traditional Shona mbira music

  • Watch the google doodle all about the mbira(if you haven’t seen it check it out- https://www.google.com/doodles/celebrating-mbira)

  • Work on sight reading rhythms(difficulty will depend on the grade)

  • Work those same rhythms along with letter names and sight reading

  • Divide into pairs and groups for simple or complex songs depending on the group. I make many of my own using Noteflight

  • I allow students to look for a song they want to learn on their own. There are many different pop songs, movie songs, etc. that you can find mbira sheet music for specifically or just use the same notation from piano sheet music.

  • I do not work with my 4th graders on chords, but I do with 5th an 6th

The last project of the year is a simple or complex composition depending on the student/group. They are allowed to pick between middle c and high f. I put the rhythms in for the first composition and then I allow them to pick their own rhythms. In 5th and 6th grade students use Noteflight and Bandlab to create and record their compositions.(if you don't know much about Noteflight and Bandlab check out my review in the link below). Students are expected to learn to play their piece and either perform it for the class or make a FlipGrid of their performance.


Happy playing!




 
 
 

Comments


Hello and thank you for stopping by!

​

 My name is Leanna O'Brien and I am a music teacher in Providence RI. I am also the founder of 

Soaring Scarves Academy.

​

The Soaring Scarves Academy was created as a place where teachers can learn how to connect abstract musical concepts(dynamics, tempo, pitch, articulation, form, timbre) to movement. This gives students a chance to move to   choreographed scarf dances all while receiving a deeper understanding of these abstract    concepts and begin to listen    to and enjoy     classical music. 

​

Let the posts
come to you.

Thanks for submitting!

Sign up and let me know what's on your mind!

Thanks for submitting!

© 2023 by Turning Heads. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page